Our reviews
Reviews from Grubhub
lukas
2 reviews
ICE CREAM WAS GREAT! CAME 20 MINUTES EARLIER!!!!! PROBABLY THE BEST ICE CREAM I HAVE EATEN.
Carlene
Top Reviewer
Im addicted to the Deep Dark Chocolate and ginger cookies.
Dillon
3 reviews
Love to support local, fresh products! Binge worthy gelato!
Sean
Top Reviewer
Ordered the Black Label and it was fantastic.
Simone
1 review
Pricey order. Never again.
Reviews from Seamless.com
Jasmine
Top Reviewer
The man who delivered my gelato was so pleasant and sweet, presenting it like a humble but precious gift-- and it was! Never tasted gelato with such fresh ingredients! And OH man, the hazelnut flavor is To LIVE For!!
angelica
1 review
Delicious craft gelato in cute containers using local products AND made in jersey city. Definitely worth it. The rose and dark chocolate gelato was absolutely worth it.
laura
Top Reviewer
This is the best gelato ever!! The chocolate is unlike any chocolate I've ever tasted. The mint chocolate chip is equally delicious. It's expensive but worth it.
Andrea
Top Reviewer
I've been a huge fan since I first visited their store last year. I can't believe they deliver now. My husband and I absolutely love their gelato! A must!
Caitlyn
Top Reviewer
Delicious and I love that the gelato is kept in a glass container instead of plastic. Next time spoons would be great!
About us
Dessert, Dinner, Ice Cream
Today
I'm Jen, the owner and chief gelato maker at Bucket & Bay. Working with my husband, Boris, we have committed to creating a unique product, using the best ingredients possible - a product we love, a product we would love to serve our friends and family. Why do we do this? Because, Like Many of you, I want my kids to look up to us and be proud that we have followed our dreams. I am also passionate about instilling in them a healthy relationship with food. To care where it comes from. To appreciate new flavors. To be inquisitive. You will note the Same passion in our open kitchen at Bucket & Bay, where we handcraft all our gelato right before your eyes. You CAN ALSO BUY AND TASTE THE MILK WE USE!